As promised from my boxing day haul, I’m slowly starting to be ready to review products for you! This liner came in the Urban Decay Perversions kit I ordered. So, I’m an eyeliner snob and a daily cat-eye girl. I prefer using liquid liners over gels because they are quicker. I find gel to be effective but you really need a good brush to use with it, or else you will not get a good shape.

This is a pen-style liquid liner. I’ve never liked pen liners because they always need to be pressed harder to actually work, and I find them to be a headache. I really did try to like this though.


The Good: Ink for Eyes is waterproof, and I had a lot of difficulty fully washing it off with plain soap, so that’s good news if you want a waterproof product. That’s about the only good thing.

The Not So Good: The ink just doesn’t flow unless you press with a certain pressure which is SO annoying, because it defeats the purpose of having a fine tip brush.

-It’s really hard to get a perfect wing since you have to press harder, causing the ink to come out as a thicker line

-You also have to tug on your skin so it is perfectly flat in order to actually draw a wing, because the brush catches on your skin otherwise. I don’t like having to do this because it can lead to wrinkles.

-The colour looks nice at first, but when it dries it just isn’t as intense black as a liquid liner should be, even after going over it several times.

Overall I found this took 5x longer than my regular inkwell liquid liner, and it just didn’t look as good. This isn’t even something I would recommend to beginners because it’s more difficult to use than it needs to be, and the colour doesn’t flow nicely. Sorry Urban Decay, this was not a hit for me.

xo J



  1. January 27, 2015 / 4:12 am

    Shame this pen wasn’t any good. I have yet to find an eyeliner liquid or gel I really love but I am not very good at eye makeup in general. I was really curious about this eyeliner too since I wanted that set but happy to hear I didn’t miss out on it too much. Great review! PS love your nails xoxox Janet

    • January 27, 2015 / 9:35 am

      Thanks so much! Yes, glad I got it in a set rather than paying full price alone :S I’ve got my eye on Tarte’s new liquid gel liner set…I’ll write a review if I get it!

      • January 27, 2015 / 1:47 pm

        Can’t wait to read it if you do get it 🙂

  2. February 2, 2015 / 5:07 am

    Ive been eyeing on this one for a while. Thanks for the review. I’ll probably just stick to my regular Motive Cosmetics eyeliner. It’s really good…I just always feel the urge to try new stuff lol 🙂

    Love your blog!

    Tracey from

    • February 4, 2015 / 1:52 am

      Thanks for reading! Yes it’s a miss 🙁 I know its hard to resist sometimes!

Thoughts on this post? Leave a comment my loves!


%d bloggers like this:

Looking for Something?